Do I Need to Be Separated from My Spouse before Filing for a Divorce?

martindale-hubble divorce lawyers in Long Island
national trial advocates in Long Island
ASLA trust badge
Super Lawyers in Long Island
avvo top attorney in Long Island
Petroske Riezenman & Meyers

Separating from a Spouse

Many people are anxious to divorce so that they can enter another relationship and possibly get re-married. Fortunately, in 2010 New York added a true no-fault ground for divorce that does not require you to be separated before filing for divorce. Although divorce can still be messy and time-consuming because there can be disagreements about any number of issues, at least there is one less issue to resolve. Before the amendment to the law, if the parties wanted to avoid a fight over whether there was a sufficient reason (or fault) to justify granting the divorce, they would have to enter into a separation agreement and then live separate and apart for a year. Only then could they avoid having to prove cruelty or adultery or one of the other fault-based grounds for divorce. Living apart for a year not only caused unnecessary delay in granting divorces, but it was often an unattainable approach because it required the parties to first agree on the resolution of all the issues in the case and incorporate that agreement into a separation agreement. Agreeing on all issues was important, because otherwise the parties could not sign a separation agreement which was required up front before the one year separation period could start to run.

About our firm
couple going through divorce in Long Island


Thankfully, the addition of the “irretrievable breakdown” ground for divorce (Domestic Relations Law §170[7]) in 2010 allows the parties to get a divorce if one of the parties is able to allege that there has been an irretrievable breakdown between the parties for the past six months. The proof can be made by affidavit, and does not require testimony. The term “irretrievable breakdown” is not defined by the statute, and proof can consist of the mere allegation that there has been an irretrievable breakdown. You can claim a break down of the marriage even if you are still living together. In short, there is little if any ability to defend against this ground for divorce, making it a fairly sure thing.


Other Relationships While the Divorce Is Pending

Technically, a sexual relationship with another person while a divorce is pending is adultery. Even if neither party has alleged adultery as a ground for divorce, adultery remains a misdemeanor level crime in New York State. This may be of some concern if you are worried about being the first person in a hundred years to be charged with the crime of adultery. If not, there is nothing to stop you from conducting yourself discretely. Discretion remains important for a couple of reasons having nothing to do with the criminality of adultery. First, if there are children, it is important to keep the children away from the paramour. Although there was a time when the moral turpitude associated with an extramarital affair would be a factor in a court’s determination of custody, today the courts are more concerned with the ability of a parent to protect his or her children by keeping children away from a paramour while the parent is still married. So, while a relationship can be a fine idea, it’s important to keep the children away from the paramour.

Second, keeping it discrete may help settle your case. Many cases that could have settled “blow up” when emotions run hot. Common sense dictates that the best course is one which involves the least potential for conflict. In other words, what your spouse doesn’t know, won’t hurt him or her.

Request a free consultation

When facing a divorce, child custody, or child support case, you deserve a lawyer who will listen to your concerns and take the time to explain your options, and who has the knowledge and experience to give you the best advice.

The best way to identify whether a Long Island divorce lawyer is right for you is to meet for an initial consultation. At Petroske Riezenman & Meyers, we are pleased to offer potential clients a free, confidential consultation where they can learn more about our experience and discuss their legal dispute. We can also offer our preliminary assessment about how the dispute will likely turn out as well as what evidence you will need for a favorable outcome.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Complete the Form or Call Now for a consultation (631)337-1977 or (516)699-1989.

Why Choose Petroske Riezenman & Meyers

There are many Long Island attorneys who will promise to aggressively represent your interests in a divorce or family law dispute.

Few have the right mix of attributes to provide cutting-edge legal representation along with compassionate support in this stressful time.

At Petroske Riezenman & Meyers, our success is built on three pillars:


Matrimonial and family law changes often. New developments come out of Albany every year, and the courts implement the law in sometimes surprising ways. To effectively protect your interests, you need a lawyer who understands the latest developments in the law, however minor. We stay informed of upcoming amendments and trends in the law. We know the latest court decisions that might impact how a judge views your case. If there is a precedent that supports your claim, we will find it and bring it to the attention of the judge.

See our Articles, FAQs and Video Library.


Family law disputes are not like other lawsuits. These disputes are governed by different laws and different judges. Although you can ask a criminal defense lawyer or an immigration attorney to handle your matrimonial or family law dispute, you should not be surprised if they are soon in over their heads and unable to provide effective representation. At Petroske Riezenman & Meyers, our attorneys and support staff have dedicated their careers to excellence and professionalism in the practice of matrimonial and family law.

Learn more About Us.


We are proud to be highly recommended by many satisfied clients we have represented over the years in divorce and Family Court cases.  We have over a century of combined experience, which allows us to perform a complete review of your case and discover facts that work to your advantage. We understand the unique challenges that family law disputes create, such as the risk of domestic violence, impediments to a negotiated resolution, or the possibility of harassing or vexatious litigation. To see the positive results we have achieved for others, check out our Client Reviews.

suffolk county long island divorce lawyers